Madeinca.ca is supported by our Canadian readers. This means we may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Read more

Casper is a leading North American mattress company known for making some of the best all-foam mattresses available in Canada. Casper’s range of mattresses, bedding and pillows, have a host of unique features and qualities that you won’t find in other North American mattresses. Today we will compare two of their popular mattresses, the Casper Original Mattress and the Casper Select Mattress.

Casper Original vs Casper Select: Which is Better for You?

The Casper Original and the Casper Select are both excellent Casper mattresses available in Canada. Made of similar materials, but featuring unique construction and qualities, each of these mattresses offers something for everyone, whether you seek temperature control, motion isolation or edge support. Today’s review will compare the Casper Original and the Casper Select and help you decide which of these two mattresses is the best option.

Who Should Buy the Casper Original Mattress

Who Should Buy the Casper Select Mattress

  • Canadians who have a Costco membership
  • Those who need extra pressure relief
  • Side sleepers and back sleepers
  • Budget-conscious Canadians

Quick Overview

Casper Original Mattress
Made in CA Exclusive Offer

Get Up to 10% OFF Your Casper Mattress Purchase

Check Price at Casper

It's Great For:

It's Great For:

Mattress Construction

The Casper Original and the Casper Select are constructed very similarly other all-foam mattresses from Casper. They do have some slight differences, though, so let’s look at how these two mattresses in our review today compare in their materials and construction.

Casper Original Mattress Layers

Casper Original Mattress Construction
  • Casper Cover. This breathable and soft cover helps with airflow, releasing trapped heat away from your body.
  • Airscape Foam. This top foam layer has small holes perforated throughout, drawing heat in and away from your body while expelling cool air. This layer does an excellent job of cooling for moderately warm sleepers.
  • Zoned Support Foam. Unique to Casper is their three-zoned support foam, which is great for those needing pressure relief. Each section supports hips, back and shoulders in different ways for maximum relief.
  • Durable Base. This thick high-density foam base helps those who need alignment support and motion isolation for those who co-sleep. This foundation helps prevent overall mattress breakdown over time. 

Casper Select Mattress Layers

  • Casper Cover. This zip-off cover can be washed with regular bedding while providing breathability for a cool night’s sleep. 
  • Airscape Foam. Made of foam with small perforated holes throughout, this foam layer doesn’t retain heat as many other memory foams do. This layer is great for those who need help with temperature control due to sleeping warm. 
  • Transition Foam. A small layer of memory foam helps with motion isolation for those who co-sleep and additional pressure relief for achy joints.
  • Zoned Support Foam. For Canadians needing extra pressure relief, this unique three-sectioned zoned support layer targets your shoulders, back and hips separately for ultimate support.
  • Durable Base. Made of high-density foam, the foundation of the Casper Select is great for total alignment as well as providing motion isolation for those who co-sleep. This base contributes to the long-lasting durability you can expect from a Casper mattress. 

Firmness

As medium-firm mattresses, the Casper Original and the Casper Select Mattress are excellent choices for those seeking a firmer and more supportive sleeping experience. For Canadians looking for a plush and soft mattress, these two Casper models may prove to be too firm for their liking. Both mattresses provide an equally firm surface, and neither has an advantage over the other.

Casper Original Mattress Firmness

7 on Firmness Scale

Ranking at a 7 out of 10 on our firmness scale, the Casper Original Mattress is great for Canadians looking for a firm mattress. Those with joint or back pain will appreciate the pressure relief from the firm sleeping surface. Those seeking a cloud-like mattress that you can seek into might find this mattress to be too firm. Overall, this is a great pick for a supportive and firm mattress, especially for back and side sleepers.

Casper Select Mattress Firmness

7 on Firmness Scale

Also ranking as a medium-firm mattress, the Casper Select Mattress also comes in at 7 on our firmness scale. For side and back sleepers, the zoned support layers help provide maximum pressure relief and support. For Canadians looking for an ultra-plush mattress, the Casper Select may be too firm for their comfort. This mattress provides an excellent sleeping experience for those seeking comfort and relief.

Durability

Both made from multiple all-foam layers, the Casper Original and the Casper Select are designed to stand the test of time. Though they have similar material usage, they feature a different number of layers and have unique sleeping experiences. The Casper Select has an advantage in our durability category today, as it features more layers, contributing to less breakdown and better overall durability.

Casper Original Mattress Durability

Made of three foam layers, the Casper Original mattress has more layers than many other memory foam mattresses on the market. More layers of a mattress can help with the overall lifespan of the mattress. With a base made of high-density foam and a 10-year limited warranty, the Casper Original is a good pick for Canadians who hope to own their mattress for as long as possible.

Casper Select Mattress Durability

As a winner in our durability category, the Casper Select features four total foam layers, ensuring less mattress breakdown over time. With the added layer of foam compared to the Casper Original, this mattress is thicker and more durable. Its high-density foam base helps with long usage compared to many other memory foam mattresses, and its 10-year limited warranty makes this a top choice for those who hope to own their mattress for a long time. 

Casper Original Mattress
Casper Original Mattress
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses.
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses. Show Less

Casper Select Mattress
Casper Select Mattress
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses.
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses. Show Less

Motion Isolation

For Canadians who co-sleep or happen to have pets or children that are active in their bed, choosing a mattress that helps with motion isolation can be essential for a good night’s sleep. Both the Casper Original and the Casper Select mattresses do a good job helping to stop motion transfer before it starts, but the Casper Select performs better in this category with an added layer of transition foam that helps with motion isolation.

Casper Original Mattress Motion Isolation

Casper Mattress Ease of Movement

The Casper Original Mattress does a good job with motion isolation but does not altogether eliminate it. With its zoned support layer, paired with the high-density foam base, the two layers work hard to prevent the feeling of motion transfer between co-sleepers. For the majority of sleepers, the level of motion isolation this mattress provides will be enough to prevent disruptive sleep.

Casper Select Mattress Motion Isolation

Performing better than the Casper Original Mattress, the Casper Select features an additional layer of transition foam designed to help with motion isolation between restless partners. The Casper Select is a great option for co-sleepers who find themselves being woken up throughout the night due to their partner tossing and turning and is the winner in our motion isolation category.

Temperature Control

For those who sleep naturally warm or wake up hot and sweaty, finding a mattress with great temperature control can be crucial to a comfortable night’s sleep. Often, all foam mattresses do not significantly reduce temperatures and can leave sleepers waking up hot and uncomfortable. The Casper mattresses in our review today both do a good job reducing heat, and neither performs better than the other in our temperature control category.

Casper Original Mattress Temperature Control

The Casper Original Mattress does a good job of helping sleepers regulate their temperature while sleeping due to its cover and top foam layer. The cover of the Casper Original is breathable and airy, drawing heat away from the body. With its top Airscape foam layer, the small holes perforated throughout the mattress draw heat in and expel cool air out. These two layers will keep moderately warm sleepers cool while sleeping, but those that sleep extra hot may need additional cooling sheets to combat waking up hot.

Casper Select Mattress Temperature Control

Like the Casper Original, the Casper Select also works hard at keeping Canadians cool throughout the night. The Casper Select features a top cover made of breathable fabric that allows warm air to be wicked away from your body. The top layer made of Airscape foam is made of tiny holes that draw in heat and expel cool air out, keeping sleepers comfortable and preventing them from overheating. Canadians who sleep extremely warm or those living in hot climates may want to seek out cooling sheets and a duvet cover to further reduce temperatures.

Edge Support

For Canadians who sleep on or near the edge of the bed regularly, choosing a mattress with great edge support can be vital. Often, memory foam mattresses do not have any specific edge support features in place, and this includes both of our Casper mattresses in our review today. The extra layer of foam that the Casper Select has that the Casper Original lacks helps secure them as a winner in the edge support category.

Casper Original Mattress Edge Support

While the Casper Original Mattress does not have any edge support measures in place, they do offer multiple foam layers, which helps with overall sinking and sagging over time. Typically, more layers of foam do a better job of keeping the edges supported versus mattresses with just one layer. As a medium-firm mattress, the Casper Original does a moderate job of helping keep the perimeter of the bed supported and firm over time.

Casper Select Mattress Edge Support

Casper Select Mattress Edge Support

Like the Casper Original, the Casper Select Mattress does not have any specific edge support features in place to prevent edge breakdown. With its high-density foam base and an extra layer of transition foam, the Casper Select does a slightly better job than the Casper Orignal Mattress in edge support. Also a medium-firm mattress, the Casper Select will not sink and sag as faster as softer mattresses in the Canadian marketplace.

Pricing

While both mattresses are made by the same company, these two Casper mattresses offer different features and sleeping experiences. It is worth noting that the Casper Select Mattress is only available from Costco, so a Costco membership is required to purchase one. The price of the Casper Select is lower, as there is a cost-saving associated with being bought at Costco; however, there are no twin sizes available for this mattress.

While the Casper Original Mattress is more expensive than the Casper Select, you can decide whether that price difference is something you need to consider after comparing the models. Here are the prices for each size available for both Casper mattresses in our review today.

Size Casper Original Mattress Casper Select Mattress
Twin
$895
N/A
Twin XL
$995
N/A
Full/Double
$1195
$549
Queen
$1295
$649
King
$1695
$849
California King
$1695
N/A

Casper Original Mattress
Casper Original Mattress
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses.
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses. Show Less

Casper Select Mattress
Casper Select Mattress
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses.
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses. Show Less

Shipping

When deciding to buy a mattress online, comparing shipping costs and speeds can be a deciding factor. Casper and Costco both provide free shipping to most locations throughout Canada. Those living in more remote areas could face additional shipping fees. Though delivery times vary, typically, Costco will deliver quicker than ordering directly from Casper.

Casper Original Mattress Shipping

Casper ships their mattresses from their warehouses, which are located throughout the United States and Canada. Shipping is free unless you live in select territories or Northern Canada. You can expect your new Casper mattress within 3-9 business days after it leaves the warehouse.

For those who wish to remove their old mattress and help set up their new one, Casper offers in-home service for an additional $249. This in-home service will take away your old mattress and help place your new one; however, it can add up to two weeks of shipping time to your order.

Casper Select Mattress Shipping

The Casper Select Mattress is only available from Costco and is not shipped from Casper warehouses. Costco keeps these mattresses in stock throughout their Canadian stores, and delivery takes approximately 5-7 business days from the day you place an order, making it quicker than the shipping of the Casper Original. Those living in remote Canadian locations may face an additional fee; otherwise, UPS shipping is included in the cost. Costco does not offer an in-home delivery service for the Casper Select Mattress.

Sleep Trial and Returns

When choosing between mattresses, looking at the sleep trial and return policies is important to understand so you are protected in case you are unhappy with your new mattress purchase. The Casper Original and the Casper Select mattresses offer 100-night sleep trials, but their return policies differ slightly.

Casper Original Mattress Sleep Trials and Returns

The Casper Original Mattress includes a 100-night sleep trial, and you must have owned the mattress for at least 30 days before you can initiate a return. If you are still unhappy with the Casper Original after 30 days, you can reach out to Casper customer service and they will coordinate a time to pick up the mattress. All returns of a Casper mattress require the mattress to be in good condition and free of stains and rips. Once Casper picks up the mattress, they will donate it to a local charity and issue a refund, which can take 3-10 business days to process.

Casper Select Mattress Sleep Trials and Returns

The Casper Select Mattress includes the same 100-night sleep trial as the Casper Original, though you must go through Costco for a return and pickup of the mattress.

To start a return, you must go through the Costco online portal and request them to pick up the mattress within the 100-night sleep trial. It does not state you must have owned the mattress for any specific length of time before returning it. It is worth considering that the entire process, from pickup to refund, can take 3-4 weeks in total, which is much longer than ordering direct from Casper.

Warranty

For long-term peace of mind and getting the longest time out of your mattress, choosing a mattress with a great warranty is key. Both of the Casper mattresses in our review today are covered under the same warranty policy, located on the Casper website.

Casper Original and Casper Select Mattress Warranty

Covered with all Casper mattress purchases is a 10-year warranty. The Casper warranty covers large body idents, fault zippers, flaws in the material and manufacturing defects. The warranty does not cover normal wear or tear, damages inflicted by the user or personal comfort preference. To claim a warranty, Casper requires that you must be the original owner, have proof of purchase, and take photos of the damage being claimed. All accepted warranty claims are covered by Casper, including shipping, repairs and replacement costs.

Final Thoughts

Both the Casper Original and the Casper Select mattresses are great picks for Canadians looking for supportive and comfortable sleep. The Casper Original is excellent for moderately warm sleepers looking for pressure relief. The Casper Select is a top pick for those on a budget looking for ultimate motion isolation and durability. After comparing all the features and pricing, we are sure one of the Casper mattresses in our review today will be an excellent pick for your next mattress purchase.

Casper Original Mattress Casper Select Mattress
Firmness
Medium Firm (7/10)
Medium Firm (7/10)
Sleep Trial
100 Nights
100 Nights
Warranty
10 Years
10 Years
Mattress Construction
4/5
4/5
Durability
4/5
4.5/5
Motion Isolation
4/5
4.5/5
Temperature Control
4/5
4/5
Edge Support
3.5/5
4/5

Frequently Asked Questions

Though similarly constructed, the Casper Select has the edge over the Casper Original for long-term durability. The Casper Select features an extra foam layer, helping prevent overall mattress breakdown over time. The Casper Select is also a great choice for those who need consistent support over time.

Casper makes their mattresses throughout North America, which includes the United States and Canada. Mattresses shipped directly from Casper will come from North American warehouses, whereas the Casper Select ships from Costco locations throughout Canada. You may wait a little longer for the Casper Original Mattress when compared to the Casper Select, but the Casper Select can only be purchased with a Costco membership.

Between the Casper Original and the Casper Select, the Casper Select does a better job at motion isolation for those that co-sleep. Featuring an extra layer of transition foam, the Casper Select helps prevent motion transfer, ensuring a peaceful night’s sleep even with restless partners. Single sleepers may have better luck with the Casper Original, which comes in a Twin size.

No, the Casper Select Mattress can only be purchased through Costco. It needs to be purchased online, but you will have to sign into your Costco account to be able to make the purchase. If you don’t want to pay for the annual membership fee, you may be able to purchase the Casper Select Mattress with a membership trial. Make sure to check out your options on the Costco website to make sure.

Both of the mattresses represented in our article today are great for temperature control. Both use breathable covers and perforated AirScape foam to ensure that heat is filtered away through the mattress. If these cooling measures aren’t enough for you, you should seek out some of Casper’s cooling sheets and other bedding options to further reduce heat throughout their sleeping space.