Madeinca.ca is supported by our Canadian readers. This means we may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Read more

Casper and Novaform are two fantastic mattress companies that make high-quality mattresses available in Canada. Casper makes and ships their mattresses throughout North America, and Novaform manufactures its products entirely in the United States. While neither of these mattress companies are Canadian, both of the mattresses we are looking at today can provide great benefits for Canadian shoppers. Each mattress features unique features, which we will examine in our Casper vs Novaform review today.

Casper Original vs Novaform Mattress: Which is Better for You?

The Casper Original and the Novaform Mattress are two of the best all-foam mattresses you can buy in Canada. These mattresses offer unique sleeping experiences and features that help them stand out in the Canadian marketplace. Whether you need a mattress with motion isolation, reasonable temperature control or excellent pressure relief, the Casper Original and the Novaform mattresses are top picks. Today we will compare both mattresses and all they offer to help you decide which mattress is the best for you.

Who Should Buy the Casper Original Mattress

  • Those who sleep warm
  • Side and back sleepers
  • Canadians needing pressure relief
  • Users seeking a firm mattress

Who Should Buy the Novaform Mattress

  • Canadians who have allergies
  • Those who need extra pressure relief
  • All sleeping positions
  • Budget-conscious Canadians

Quick Overview

Casper Original Mattress
Made in CA Exclusive Offer

Get 20% OFF Your Casper Mattress Purchase

Check Price at Casper

It's Great For:

It's Great For:

Mattress Construction

The Casper Original and the Novaform mattresses are constructed very similarly, as they are each all-foam mattresses with four total layers. Both mattresses feature a unique cover and three layers of foam that offer unique benefits and features. Let’s take a look at the Casper Original and the Novaform mattresses and how they compare in materials and construction.

Casper Original Mattress Layers

Casper Original Mattress Construction
  • Casper Cover. This soft and breathable cover allows air to flow freely, wicking heat and moisture away from the body for a comfortable night’s sleep.
  • Airscape Foam. This top layer of foam is constructed with small holes throughout it, sucking warm air in and expelling cool air out. Unlike other memory foam mattresses, this layer doesn’t retain heat.
  • Zoned Support Foam. This unique foam layer to Casper has three different zoned support sections, each targeting separate pressure points throughout the body, allowing maximum support and comfort. 
  • Durable Base. Made of high-density foam, this thick base layer of the Casper Original helps those needing alignment support and prevents sinking and sagging over time. 

Novaform Mattress Layers

Novaform Mattress Construction 1
  • Fresh Cover. The cover of the Novaform mattress features an easy-to-remove top layer that can be washed regularly, perfect for those with allergies. Specially treated to prevent mould and bacteria, this antimicrobial cover is unique to Novaform.
  • LURACor Foam Top Layer. This top foam layer is infused with copper, keeping the mattress clean and fresh. For those needing pressure relief, this layer helps with supporting joints and pain.
  • Memory Foam Layer. Made of high-quality memory foam, this layer provides additional cushioning and support and reduces motion transfer between partners. 
  • Base Layer. Made of high-density foam, this base layer helps with long-term durability and prevents the sinking and sagging that can occur over time. 

Firmness

Both the Casper Original and the Novaform mattresses are considered medium-firm mattresses, great for those needing extra support. For Canadians looking for a plush, soft sleeping surface, neither mattress will be as soft as you may desire. Of the two mattresses, the Casper Original is firmer and better suited for anyone needing extra pressure relief because of sleeping positions or pain and is our winner for those looking for a firm sleeping surface.

Casper Original Mattress Firmness

7 on Firmness Scale

The Casper Original Mattress is a medium firm mattress that ranks 7 out of 10 on our firmness scale. Side and back sleepers and those needing extra pressure relief will appreciate the firm but supportive sleeping surface. Casper’s three-zoned support layer helps target your shoulders, back and hips to alleviate pain while sleeping. As the firmest and most supportive mattress in our review today, the Casper Original is the winner in our firmness category.

Novaform Mattress Firmness

6.5 on Firmness Scale

Also a medium-firm mattress, the Novaform Mattress comes in at a 6.5 on our firmness scale. As a slightly softer mattress than the Casper Original, all sleeping positions will find this mattress comfortable and supportive. Those that sleep on their stomach will find the cushioning of the Novaform comfortable, and those that sleep on their side and back will enjoy the pressure relief measures. Those seeking additional pressure relief may wish to consider the Casper Original, though, as it offers more for those suffering from joint pain.

Durability

Constructed of high-quality foam layers, both the Casper Original and the Novaform are designed to be durable mattresses that will last many years. Each of the two mattresses features three total foam layers, including a high-density foam base, helping prevent mattress breakdown over time. Although they are similarly constructed in their materials, the Novaform has an advantage over the Casper Original, as it has a warranty that is twice as long.

Casper Original Mattress Durability

Made of three foam layers, the Casper Original mattress is more durable than many other memory foam mattresses that may only feature one or two layers. Mattresses with multiple layers of foam help with overall mattress breakdown. The base of the Casper Original is made of high-density foam, increasing its durability. With a 10-year limited warranty, the Casper Original Mattress does a good job ensuring that your mattress will be in good condition for as long as possible.

Novaform Mattress Durability

Like the Casper, the Novaform is also made from 3 total foam layers, including a durable high-density foam base. With this thick foundational layer, the mattress is less likely to break down over time compared to standard foam mattresses. As the most durable mattress in our review, the Novaform features a very long, 20-year limited warranty, which is much longer than most mattresses on the market.

Casper Original Mattress
Casper Original Mattress
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses.
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses. Show Less

Novaform SoFresh Responsive Foam Mattress
Novaform SoFresh Responsive Foam Mattress
Made in CA readers get the best price on Novaform mattresses.
Made in CA readers get the best price on Novaform mattresses. Show Less

Motion Isolation

For Canadians who co-sleep and have restless partners, choosing a mattress with good motion isolation can be an important factor when buying a new mattress. The Casper Original and the Novaform mattresses do a good job of preventing motion transfer between partners, though the Novaform outperforms the Casper Original with its transition foam layer.

Casper Original Mattress Motion Isolation

Casper Mattress Ease of Movement

Doing a better job than most memory foam mattresses, the Casper Original mattress does a decent job with motion isolation. The zoned support layer paired with its high-density foam base helps minimize the feeling of movement between partners, though it does not eliminate it completely. This mattress will do a good job for most sleepers, but those with highly restless partners or pets may want to choose the Novaform Mattress, which does a better job stopping motion transfer.

Novaform Mattress Motion Isolation

The Novaform Mattress is the winner in our motion isolation category, as co-sleepers will experience very little motion transfer. The memory foam transition layer, paired with the supportive high-density foam base, helps combat motion transfer between even the most active sleepers or pets. For Canadians who value motion isolation, the Novaform Mattress is worth considering.

Temperature Control

For those who naturally sleep warm or live in hot climates, choosing a mattress that can help reduce temperature is crucial. No one likes waking up hot and sweaty, and often all-foam mattresses can retain heat throughout the night. While both mattresses in our review today do a good job with temperature control, the Casper Original is our pick for the best cooling mattress we’re looking at today.

Casper Original Mattress Temperature Control

As the winner in our review for temperature control, the Casper Original Mattress does a great job of helping Canadians keep cool throughout the night. With a breathable and airy cover, the Casper Original allows air to circulate without trapping heat close to your body. This mattress features a top layer of Airscape foam made of tiny holes throughout, sucking the warm air in and expelling cool air out. For most Canadians who sleep moderately warm, this mattress will cover their needs, but those who sleep extra hot may need additional cooling measures like sheets or a duvet cover to further reduce body temperature.

Novaform Mattress Temperature Control

The Novaform Mattress has no specific measures to combat rising temperatures. Its top layer of LURAcor foam does help with minimal heat reduction, as the copper-infused material draws some heat away from the body. For those that sleep hot, choosing the Casper Original Mattress may be a better pick to sleep comfortably.

Edge Support

Many Canadians tend to sleep near the edge of the bed or sit there often enough that they may wonder about edge support. A mattress with good edge support measures in place with prevent the perimeter of the mattress from sinking or sagging over time. Usually, all-foam mattresses do not include any specific edge support measures in place, and this includes the two mattresses we are comparing today. While neither the Casper Original nor the Novaform mattresses have unique edge support features, the Casper does a slightly better job being the firmest in our review and least likely to sag over time.

Casper Original Mattress Edge Support

While the Casper Original Mattress does not provide any edge support features, the multiple foam layers the mattress is comprised of help with general sinking and sagging over time. Being the firmest mattress of the two we are reviewing today helps the Casper Original have an advantage over the Novaform, as the density of the layers won’t break down as quickly.

Novaform Mattress Edge Support

Novaform Mattress Edge Support

Like the Casper Original, the Novaform Mattress does not include any edge support measures to help with sinking at the perimeter of the bed. This mattress will still do a good job with overall edge support, as it has multiple foam layers and a high-density base that help with sagging over time. While there may be a better mattress for long-term edge support, most Canadians will be happy with the support that it gives.

Pricing

One of the most important factors when deciding which mattress to buy is the price. While the Casper Original is more expensive than the Novaform Mattress, the cost difference may be insignificant for some Canadians. We recommend choosing a mattress based on overall features, policies and also cost when buying a mattress. Here are the prices for each size available for both the Casper Original and the Novaform Mattress.

Size Casper Original Mattress Novaform Mattress
Twin
$895
$599
Twin XL
$995
N/A
Full/Double
$1195
$689
Queen
$1295
$749
King
$1695
$899
California King
$1695
N/A

Casper Original Mattress
Casper Original Mattress
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses.
Made in CA readers get the best price on Casper mattresses. Show Less

Novaform SoFresh Responsive Foam Mattress
Novaform SoFresh Responsive Foam Mattress
Made in CA readers get the best price on Novaform mattresses.
Made in CA readers get the best price on Novaform mattresses. Show Less

Shipping

Anytime you make an online purchase, you have to consider shipping speeds and costs when deciding between two products. Casper and Costco provide free shipping to most locations throughout Canada, thorough those that live in more remote areas may need to pay additional fees. Shipping speeds vary, but Casper typically will deliver their Original mattress faster than Costco will deliver the Novaform.

Casper Original Mattress Shipping

When you buy a mattress directly from Casper, you can expect free shipping to most addresses within Canada. Casper manufactures and ships their mattresses throughout North America, and your mattress will ship out of whichever warehouse is closest to you. Typically, Casper mattresses are delivered between 3-9 business days from the time the mattress leaves the warehouse.

Unique to Casper is their optional add-on service that costs $249 and includes in-home setup and removal of your old mattress. Those who choose this service can expect delivery to take up to two full weeks from the time you place your order.

Novaform Mattress Shipping

Novaform mattresses that are purchased through Costco are free in most areas within Canada. A small fee may be added for remote locations and those living in select territories. Costco ships their Novaform mattresses via a standard carrier, and delivery has to be coordinated with the customer directly. You can expect delivery of a Novaform mattress from Costco to take 10-20 business days, so this may not be the best option for those in a hurry. Costco does not offer an in-home setup and removal option.

Sleep Trial and Returns

For those worried they may not be happy with their new mattress, having an excellent sleep trial and return policy may be one of the most important things to consider when shipping a new mattress. The policies between buying Casper directly and the Novaform through Costco vary greatly, with Casper having the clearest policies in place and easiest return procedures.

Casper Original Mattress Sleep Trials and Returns

Every purchase of a Casper mattress includes a 100-night sleep trial where you can decide if you are happy with your mattress. Casper does require you to have owned the mattress for at least 30 days before contacting customer service to start a return. If you are unhappy with your Casper Original Mattress and 30 days have passed, they will work with you to coordinate a time to pick up the mattress, assuming it is in good condition and free of stains and rips. Caper will cover the cost of picking up and donating the mattress, and once this is complete, you can expect a refund to the original form of payment within 3-10 business days.

Novaform Mattress Sleep Trials and Returns

Novaform mattresses purchased through Costco do not include a sleep trial with a set time frame. Costco will accept returns if you are unhappy with the purchase, but they do not list a designated time frame in which this must be done, only requesting that you contact customer service, and they will help you on a case-by-case basis. Costco will pick up the mattress you wish to return and refund you, but expect the entire process to take 3-4 weeks.

Warranty

Anytime you buy a mattress, it is a good idea to think long-term and ensure that your purchase will be covered if there are any issues. Both of the mattresses in our review today come with great warranties; however, the Novaform Mattress is a winner in this category, with a warranty that is double the length of the Casper Original. For both mattresses, in order to claim a warranty, make sure you register your product, keep the receipt and ensure the tags are still attached to the mattress.

Casper Original Mattress Warranty

All Casper mattresses are covered by a 10-year limited warranty. This warranty will cover things like faulty zippers, manufacturing defects, large body indents and other physical flaws. It will not cover issues like comfort preference or damage caused by the customer. Casper will usually ask you to register your product, take photos of the damage, and submit your sales receipt to file a warranty claim. If the claim is approved, Casper will cover all shipping and repair costs as needed.

Novaform Mattress Warranty

Novafom mattresses, regardless of where they are purchased from, include a generous limited warranty of 20 years. This warranty includes things like defects in fabric and craft, as well as faulty zippers and body indents. Like most warranties, it does not include customer preference on comfort or size or rips and damage caused by the user. Make sure to register your Novaform mattress upon purchase on their website and submit all requested paperwork. It is worth noting that while the warranty is longer than that of the Casper mattress, Novaform requires you to pay for shipping costs in all directions, which can add up to be potentially costly.

Final Thoughts

The Casper Original and the Novaform mattresses are excellent options for those looking to buy a new mattress in Canada. Those seeking temperature control and a great sleep trial policy may want to consider the Casper Original. For Canadians looking for motion isolation and a long warranty, the Novaform is an excellent choice. After comparing all the features, pricing and brand policies, we are confident that one of these mattresses will be a perfect option for your next mattress.

Casper Original Mattress Novaform Mattress
Firmness
Medium Firm (7/10)
Medium Firm (6.5/10)
Sleep Trial
100 Nights
N/A
Warranty
10 Years
20 Years
Mattress Construction
4/5
4/5
Durability
4/5
4.5/5
Motion Isolation
4/5
4.5/5
Temperature Control
4.5/5
4/5
Edge Support
3.5/5
3.5/5

Frequently Asked Questions

While both of the mattresses are constructed similarly, the motion isolation in the Novaform Mattress is superior to the Casper. It uses a layer of memory foam that targets motion as it happens, reducing what you’ll feel on the other side of the bed. Canadians that sleep with a partner, children, or pets can appreciate how much this mattress isolates motion.

The Casper Original Mattress is made throughout the United States and Canada, but you can’t be sure where the mattress you buy will be manufactured or shipped from. Novaform mattresses are solely made in the United States and sold throughout Canada in Costco locations. You will need a Costco membership in order to purchase this mattress, and it will ship to your address from a Canadian warehouse.

Between the Casper Original and the Novaform Mattress, the Casper Original does a better job of keeping sleepers cool. A breathable cover and AirScape foam layer draw heat away from your body as you sleep. This mattress neutralizes heat to keep the core of the mattress cool and comfortable regardless of how hot you sleep. 

The Novaform Mattress does not feature a sleep trial. Costco will accept returns if you aren’t happy with your purchase. However, there is no set time frame to determine if the mattress works for you, but you must contact customer service on a case-by-case basis to process a mattress return.

No, you cannot purchase the Novaform Mattress without a Costco membership. In order to purchase this mattress, you have to pay for an annual Costco membership plan. You may be able to purchase the mattress on a membership trial, but you should contact Costco or look through their membership policies to determine if this is necessary.